False Dichotomies


Breaking news from Gaza

Do not believe what you read about an Israeli ground operation. A ceasefire has been called, based on the interventions of Annie Lennox. Falsedi correspondent The Hoth has managed to break the stupid Israeli ban on journalists. He reports live…

In a carefully worded statement released on the eighth day of Operation Cast Lead, Israel’s security cabinet confirmed that it would be “running down” the offensive, in a move widely-expected after high-level diplomatic calls for a ceasefire on Friday. Addressing a news conference in Tel Aviv, a shaken-looking Ehud Barak – Israel’s defence minister – later explained the decision, singling out Annie Lennox’s call for a hiatus in the bombing as “the final nail in the coffin”. 

“Whilst we are not keen to be seen to kowtow to demands from the outside world, there are occasions when we have to acknowledge where the protests are emanating from, and the impact of their words on future negotiations”, he said. “Annie Lennox has, for a long time now, been a major behind-the-scenes player in the Middle East peace process, and is fast becoming a significant actor in political circles”, he continued. “For her to break cover and go public with her petition was not something we [the government] felt we could ignore, hence our decision to bring an end to Cast Lead”.

Scenes of jubilation in Gaza greeted the Israeli announcement, with Hamas immediately declaring Lennox a “living shaheed”, urging all the group’s supporters to purchase as much of Lennox’s back catalogue as possible, in order to demonstrate their commitment to the cause. “And not just the early stuff, either”, boomed Hamas musical attaché Mahmoud Al-Suwani from a hastily-assembled stage in a crowded Gaza square. “Her solo albums also deserve to be recognised by the united Palestinian people. Particularly ‘Medusa’, which – despite being comprised of cover songs – still ranks up there with anything the Eurythmics released beforehand”.

In the southern Israeli town of Sderot, which bore the brunt of Hamas’ Kassam rocket fire for several years, residents retreated from their previous hawkish positions upon hearing of Lennox’s plea – acknowledging that “there are times to fight, and times to accede to the demands of somewhat washed-up and irrelevant lesbian icons”, according to Sderot’s mayor. “Whilst we are sorry that doyens of the eighties rock scene haven’t granted our military sufficient time in which to complete their mission, we nonetheless are grateful to have been allowed as much leeway as we have to carry out at least part of our task – despite earlier setbacks”.

He was thought to have been referring to last week’s minor political spat involving three of Queen’s backing singers, who issued an unofficial statement via Sony BMG calling for an unconditional ceasefire, before swiftly retracting the demand amid rumours of infighting between various soft-rock factions involved in the peace process.

 This is not the first time that the worlds of popular music and unpopular military campaigns have collided – as witnessed earlier this year, when Ethiopia’s ruling party finally caved in to pressure from A-Ha frontman Morten Harket and withdrew their troops from Somalia. At the time, Harket’s intervention was predicted by many commentators as heralding a new age of blurred boundaries between international diplomacy and Top 40 songsmiths.

 “In an era when domestic public opinion is shaped by the stars of yesteryear, it is not unthinkable that generals of armed forces around the world will also sit up and take note when platinum-selling stadium gods speak out about the wisdom of their military strategies”, wrote Simon Jenkins in the Guardian. “Furthermore, with the likes of Paula Abdul able to marshal millions of votes supporting her proclamations on American Idol every week, the logical next step could see armies and militias deciding their tactics on the basis of a ‘Strictly Come Carpet-Bombing’ interaction with the TV-watching public”.

Defence Minister Barak has, it is believed, privately expressed his support for such a move in relation to Israel’s forty-one year occupation of the West Bank. Sources close to his staff suggest that he is ready to utilise mass-telephonic voting in order to avoid deeply unpopular moves such as the infamous Disengagement of 2005. “Back then, the government relied on the advice of Bananarama to make up their minds about the move”, an anonymous diplomat stated. “At the time, it seemed entirely rational to canvass, and act upon, the opinion of those who had achieved chart success via saccharine pop music twenty years ago in another continent, but in hindsight it wasn’t the Israeli government’s finest hour”.

With that in mind, he was sceptical of the wisdom of Barak’s latest move. “Whilst acceding to Lennox might shore up international opinion in the short term, going forward it would seem far wiser to rely on weekly Saturday night viewers’ votes to help us decide how to rid the scourge of Islamic terror and fundamentalism from our midst”. Lennox herself was unavailable for comment in the wake of the ceasefire, her spokesman announcing that she had immediately turned her attention to tackling the ever-deteriorating situation in Angola, in which she had the “unwavering support” of political titan Roland Rat and his aide-de-camp Kevin the Gerbil.


18 Comments so far

  1. Maddy January 3rd, 2009 10:16 pm

    Funny boy x

  2. eamonn January 3rd, 2009 10:57 pm

    a masterpiece

  3. the hoth January 3rd, 2009 11:08 pm

    i think she means funny hoth x

  4. LB January 3rd, 2009 11:43 pm

    Annie Lennox, following on the heels of the Dixie Chicks’ success in ending the Iraq war, is a real inspiration…

  5. Karl Pfeifer January 4th, 2009 12:54 am

    Could you kindly explain who Annie Lennox is?
    Karl Pfeifer, Vienna

  6. Gabriel January 4th, 2009 8:28 am

    Very funny!

  7. Alex Stein January 4th, 2009 12:22 pm
  8. Chas Newkey-Burden January 4th, 2009 8:57 pm

    This rules! Where have you been all my life?!

  9. nick January 4th, 2009 9:38 pm

    sorry to sound humourless, but the timing of this is in pretty bad taste considering what’s happening. and I think it’s slightly unfair to cast her as another bono, given that – according to hp, and an interview given yesterday – she’s been one of the few people to stick her neck out about the qassams as well as criticise the current escalation. her brief comments on the news were much more apposite than tony benn’s pompous utterences. it’d be a shame if you lost potential readers because of this, however funny it would have been at another point.

  10. Gert January 4th, 2009 10:29 pm

    A sad post. Not funny at all. Popstars obviously shouldn’t be allowed to speak out without being mocked by the Ivory Tower.

  11. Alex January 4th, 2009 11:35 pm

    Gert – it was the Hoth, not me…

  12. Gert January 5th, 2009 6:32 pm
  13. Alex January 5th, 2009 8:38 pm

    I’m very dubious as to the authenticity of that recording…

  14. Peter D January 5th, 2009 9:51 pm

    I don’t find it too funny, no. In some years time, Annie Lennox and other people who had the moral clarity to say something like that (and some guts, given how easy it seems to be to ridicule them) will be remembered as the sane people in the house, and some, like Gideon Levy, as the righteous of Sodom.

  15. Gert January 7th, 2009 8:25 pm

    “I’m very dubious as to the authenticity of that recording…”

    Spoken like a true trooper of the Apartheid State of Zion… First rule of the ASZ: “DENY EVERYTHING…”

  16. Alex January 7th, 2009 8:30 pm

    Gert – you seem to be becoming increasingly unreasonable. Expressing doubt does not equate to denial. As for the ASZ stuff, I would be weary of hysteria – it generally doesn’t do much good.

  17. Avram January 9th, 2009 2:12 pm

    ha ha Gert … another liberal, ultra left winger … The question should be, what truth don’t YOU own? I mean, you own it all after all …

  18. Rerteramb March 14th, 2011 3:20 pm

    Sulfa Drugs Discovery http://criminalrecordreportfree.org/ – clonazepam no prescription Klonopin is preferred by many because it has a short half life, a low toxicity, and it begins to work quickly so that symptoms can easily be controlled. purchase klonopin online

Leave a reply